We use Smarter Select (www.smarterselect.com) to manage our scholarship and grant applications. The staff feedback has been very good. It's been a little more difficult for our reviewers to read other reviewers' scores online but when they change to the print view, it works well for them. We've used it 2 years now. 

Our scholarship and grant site was developed by an organization called Morether. I am happy to share their contact information with you. We have been very pleased with it's capabilities and the service we receive from their support. My email is kristy@templeeducationfoundation.org and I'll share my contact.

I have not worked for an organization that utilizes it, but I have worked with organizations that use Foundant for Grantmakers and have heard the online ease of use and review is simplified. Not a personal recommendation, just sharing another resource.

thanks everyone for your suggestions and input.